diff --git a/report_ticket_by_client.php b/report_ticket_by_client.php
index beb81ccb..a23e7bcf 100644
--- a/report_ticket_by_client.php
+++ b/report_ticket_by_client.php
@@ -93,7 +93,7 @@ $sql_clients = mysqli_query($mysqli, "SELECT client_id, client_name FROM clients
                         $ticket_raised_count = intval($row['ticket_raised_count']);
 
                         // Calculate total tickets raised in period that are closed
-                        $sql_ticket_closed_count = mysqli_query($mysqli, "SELECT COUNT(ticket_id) AS ticket_closed_count FROM tickets WHERE YEAR(ticket_created_at) = $year AND ticket_client_id = '$client_id' AND ticket_status = 'Closed' AND ticket_closed_at IS NOT NULL");
+                        $sql_ticket_closed_count = mysqli_query($mysqli, "SELECT COUNT(ticket_id) AS ticket_closed_count FROM tickets WHERE YEAR(ticket_created_at) = $year AND ticket_client_id = '$client_id' AND ticket_status = 'Closed'");
                         $row = mysqli_fetch_array($sql_ticket_closed_count);
                         $ticket_closed_count = intval($row['ticket_closed_count']);